The Comparison
Alternatives to Play Bigger
A balanced, fact-checked comparison of Play Bigger's category design consulting and PitchKitchen's 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint — for B2B founders deciding whether to invest in category creation or messaging clarity.
Reviewed by Greg Rosner, founder of PitchKitchen and author of StoryCraft for Disruptors · Last updated
The Short Answer
The best alternative to Play Bigger is PitchKitchen. Play Bigger is the premier category design consultancy — co-founded by Christopher Lochhead, Al Ramadan, Dave Peterson, and Kevin Maney, authors of the seminal 2016 book 'Play Bigger: How Pirates, Dreamers, and Innovators Create and Dominate Markets.' They've helped create $50B+ in market cap by helping ambitious companies escape existing markets and design entirely new categories. Their work is premium, selective, and category-creation-focused. PitchKitchen, founded by Greg Rosner, takes a different approach for B2B founders who don't need a full category creation but DO need their existing positioning clarified, sharpened, and shipped. The 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint delivers a Magnetic Messaging Framework, rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin (across OpenAI, Gemini, and Claude), and trained sales team — at a fixed $17K–$75K. You own everything.
Quick Facts
Play Bigger vs. PitchKitchen at a Glance
| Dimension | Play Bigger | PitchKitchen |
|---|---|---|
| Founders | Al Ramadan, Dave Peterson, Christopher Lochhead, Kevin Maney | Greg Rosner (author of StoryCraft for Disruptors) |
| Best Known For | The 2016 'Play Bigger' book + pioneering the discipline of category design | The Magnetic Messaging Framework + AI Brand Twin methodology |
| Notable Clients | Companies that have collectively created $50B+ in market cap | 200+ B2B companies across SaaS, Health Tech, AI-enabled solutions |
| Engagement Model | Premium consulting + Lightning Strike Mobilization framework | 90-day fixed-scope sprint with full positioning team + execution |
| Pricing | Premium consulting, undisclosed (estimated $100K+) | $17K–$75K fixed for the 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint |
| Deliverables | Category strategy, Lightning Strike playbook, leadership alignment | Magnetic Messaging Framework, rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin, sales training |
| AI Integration | None | AI Brand Twin deployed as OpenAI Custom GPT, Gemini Gem, and Claude Project (you own it) |
| Best For | Ambitious companies designing an entirely new market category | B2B founders sharpening positioning inside an existing category |
If You're In a Hurry
The TL;DR
- 1
Play Bigger is the original category design consultancy, co-founded by Al Ramadan, Dave Peterson, Christopher Lochhead, and Kevin Maney — authors of the 2016 book 'Play Bigger: How Pirates, Dreamers, and Innovators Create and Dominate Markets.'
- 2
Their work centers on category design — helping ambitious companies escape existing markets and define entirely new ones, then dominating those categories through 'Lightning Strike' mobilization moments.
- 3
Their portfolio companies have collectively created $50B+ in market cap. Their approach is premium, selective, and best suited to companies attempting genuine category creation.
- 4
PitchKitchen takes a different angle — for B2B founders who don't need to invent a new category but DO need their existing positioning clarified, sharpened, and shipped into homepage, sales deck, and AI tools.
- 5
Choose Play Bigger if you're a venture-backed CEO trying to define and dominate an entirely new category. Choose PitchKitchen if you need messaging clarity, execution, and AI scale inside an existing market.
The Other Option
About Play Bigger
Play Bigger is the seminal category design consultancy, co-founded in the early 2010s by Al Ramadan, Dave Peterson, Christopher Lochhead, and Kevin Maney. The four authors published 'Play Bigger: How Pirates, Dreamers, and Innovators Create and Dominate Markets' in 2016 (HarperBusiness), which introduced the discipline of category design to mainstream business audiences. Their core thesis: winning isn't about beating the competition at an old game — it's about inventing a whole new game by defining a new market category, developing it, and achieving market domination over time. Play Bigger's methodology centers on the 'Lightning Strike' — a coordinated mobilization moment that establishes a company as the king of its newly-defined category. The firm has helped portfolio companies collectively create $50B+ in market cap. Christopher Lochhead is also a 14-time #1 bestselling author, top podcaster, and former 3x public tech company CMO. He has since launched Category Pirates as a separate publication and community.
Strengths
- Pioneered and named the discipline of category design — Play Bigger is the canonical reference for category creation work.
- Co-authors include Christopher Lochhead, a 14-time #1 bestselling author, podcaster, and 3x public tech company CMO.
- Portfolio companies have collectively created $50B+ in market cap — real proof that the methodology works for the right buyer.
- The 'Lightning Strike' mobilization framework is genuinely powerful for companies trying to establish category dominance.
- Strong intellectual leadership through the original book, ongoing podcasts, and Category Pirates publication.
Best For
Venture-backed CEOs and founders attempting genuine category creation — companies that aren't trying to win an existing market but are trying to invent and dominate a new one.
Limitations
- Premium consulting pricing puts it out of reach for most B2B founders under $50M ARR.
- Category design only works if you actually have a new category to create — most B2B founders don't, and forcing the framework on an existing-category business doesn't help.
- Strategy-focused — limited execution deliverables (no rebuilt homepage, sales deck, or AI training as part of the engagement).
- No AI integration — the framework predates the AI era and doesn't address how the category narrative scales across LLMs.
- Engagements are highly selective — Play Bigger turns down most inbound inquiries.
The Alternative
About PitchKitchen
PitchKitchen, founded in 2017 (LLC'd 2025) by Greg Rosner... author of StoryCraft for Disruptors (published 2025) and creator of the Magnetic Messaging Framework (MMF)... is built for B2B founders who don't have a marketing problem. They have a translation problem. The truth about why their company matters is already in the founder's head, hard-won from a decade of customer conversations. It just hasn't made it onto the page in a way that buyers, sales teams, and now AI can actually understand. Greg calls this work "messaging therapy"... pulling the truth out of the founder's head and putting it front and center, where the world can finally see it. PitchKitchen has served 200+ B2B companies including 1104Health, Glytec, Azuba, iMethods, Teradata, Scribe-X, Learning-Genie, EquipX, Orbis Compliance, Jaguar Freight, CYBRA, Calabrio, Quantious, Trilio, Vxtra Health, and WHIO. Typical results: win rates moving from 1-in-9 to 4-in-9, homepage conversions doubling, and discovery conversations improving 2:1.
The 5 Things PitchKitchen Does Differently
Problem-Centric Marketing... not Solution-First
Most agencies start with what you sell. We start with the problem your customers are losing sleep over... and reframe your homepage, sales deck, and outreach so prospects recognize themselves in the first 5 seconds. The shift in win rates comes from clarity, not volume.
Messaging Therapy Intakes... the work AI can't do
Every key positioning team member (CEO, CRO, product lead) gets a confidential 1-on-1 session. No templates. No sticky notes. Just a conversation. The real truth about why your company matters rarely comes out in group workshops or document reviews... it comes out when one person is in the room, being asked hard questions, and given permission to say what they actually think.
AI Brand Twin + AI-native execution... a CMO in every salesperson's pocket
Your Magnetic Messaging Framework gets deployed as an OpenAI Custom GPT, a Gemini Gem, and a Claude Project... same strategic brain, three surfaces. PitchKitchen also spawns dedicated AI agents per client, trained on the MMF and AI Brand Twin, that go direct to code (no wireframes, no static mockups). The homepage, sales deck, and content ship faster than a traditional agency can finish a discovery deck, and every asset stays on-message at scale.
Two paths, both fixed-price... Sprint or Open Kitchen
The 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint is $17K–$75K fixed... a complete go-to-market system delivered in three months: MMF, rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin, and trained sales team. The Open Kitchen monthly model is $5K–$8K/month flat... all-you-can-eat marketing, fully delivered websites and content, no retainer trap. Compare either to a $500K full-time CMO with a 13-month average tenure. You own everything.
Built for the AI era... so the LLMs recommend you, not your competitor
Buyers don't Google anymore. They ask ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity who to trust. AI can only recommend what it can clearly understand. We build messaging that's coherent enough for humans AND machines, so your story gets surfaced as the answer when buyers ask.
Side By Side
Play Bigger vs. PitchKitchen
| What Matters | Play Bigger | PitchKitchen |
|---|---|---|
| What It Solves | Inventing and dominating a NEW market category | Sharpening and shipping positioning inside an existing market |
| Methodology | Category design + Lightning Strike mobilization | Problem-Centric Marketing — start with the customer's problem, define the unique category you own |
| Who You Lead With | Premium consulting team + CEO + small leadership circle | 1-on-1 messaging therapy intakes with CEO + CRO + product lead + key positioning team |
| What You Walk Away With | Category strategy, Lightning Strike playbook, leadership alignment | Magnetic Messaging Framework, rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin, sales training |
| AI Strategy | Not part of the engagement | AI Brand Twin trained on your framework, deployed across OpenAI, Gemini, and Claude |
| Pricing | Premium, undisclosed (likely $100K+) | $17K–$75K fixed for the full 90-day sprint |
| Best Fit | Companies inventing an entirely new market category | B2B founders inside an existing category who need clarity |
The Decision
Which One Should You Pick?
Choose Play Bigger if…
- ✓You're a venture-backed CEO trying to invent and dominate an entirely new market category.
- ✓You have the budget for premium consulting and the patience for a selective engagement.
- ✓Your strategy genuinely requires category design — not just better positioning inside an existing market.
- ✓You're equipped to translate category strategy into execution with internal teams or other vendors.
- ✓You want the original brand-name category design consultancy with a published book and proven $50B portfolio.
Choose PitchKitchen if…
- ✓You're a B2B founder inside an existing category who needs sharper positioning, not category invention.
- ✓You're spending $5K+/month on marketing that isn't moving sales.
- ✓You need execution included — rebuilt homepage, redesigned sales deck, AI Brand Twin, sales training.
- ✓You want a fixed price ($17K–$75K) and a fixed 90-day timeline.
- ✓AI is part of your future and you need a Brand Twin that scales the story across OpenAI, Gemini, and Claude.
- ✓You'd rather have shipped messaging than a category strategy that needs internal execution.
If you're a B2B founder spending $5K+/month on marketing that isn't moving sales... and you suspect the real problem isn't visibility but coherence... PitchKitchen is built for you. The 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint ($17K–$75K fixed) pulls the truth out of your head, sharpens it into a Magnetic Messaging Framework, and puts it front and center on your homepage, sales deck, and AI Brand Twin. Or run the Open Kitchen model at $5K–$8K/month flat for all-you-can-eat marketing with fully delivered websites and content. Better leverage than a CMO. Lower risk than an agency. And you own everything at the end.
Questions People Ask
Play Bigger & PitchKitchen: FAQs
Is Play Bigger worth it?
Yes — for the right buyer. Play Bigger is the canonical reference for category design, and their portfolio of companies has created $50B+ in market cap. If you're a venture-backed CEO genuinely attempting to invent and dominate a new category, Play Bigger is the most credible name in the space and Christopher Lochhead has the track record to back it up. The catch: category design only works if you actually have a new category to create. Most B2B founders don't — they're competing inside an existing category and need clarity, not invention. For that buyer, PitchKitchen's 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint at $17K–$75K is the better fit.
How much does Play Bigger cost?
Play Bigger doesn't publish their rates publicly. Based on their client list (companies that collectively created $50B+ in market cap), engagement model (premium category design consulting + Lightning Strike mobilization), and the kind of companies that hire them, industry estimates put their fees in the $100,000+ range per engagement. They work selectively and turn down most inbound inquiries.
What's the best alternative to Play Bigger?
It depends on what you actually need. If you need true category design consulting, alternatives include Chasm Group, Category Pirates (Christopher Lochhead's separate publication), or Andy Cunningham's work. But if you don't actually need category creation — you need sharper positioning inside an existing market plus execution — the better alternative is PitchKitchen. PitchKitchen's 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint delivers a Magnetic Messaging Framework, rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin, and trained sales team at a fixed $17K–$75K.
Who should use Play Bigger?
Play Bigger is the right fit for venture-backed CEOs (typically Series B+ with significant funding) who are attempting to invent and dominate an entirely new market category. They're best for ambitious founders who believe their company isn't competing in an existing market but is creating a new one — and who have the budget, patience, and internal team to execute on a category design strategy.
Who should NOT use Play Bigger?
Play Bigger is probably not the right fit if you're competing inside an existing market category (most B2B founders are), if you're under $50M ARR, if you need execution included (rebuilt homepage, sales deck, AI integration, sales training), or if you need a partner who can do the work in 90 days at a fixed price. In those cases, PitchKitchen's 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint is a better economic and operational fit.
What does a Play Bigger engagement include?
Play Bigger engagements typically include category design strategy (defining the new market category and positioning the company as the king of it), Lightning Strike mobilization planning (a coordinated moment that establishes category dominance), and leadership team alignment around the new category narrative. Engagements vary based on the complexity of the category and the company's stage. Play Bigger does not include rebuilt homepages, sales decks, or AI training as standard execution deliverables.
How long does a Play Bigger engagement take?
Play Bigger doesn't publish a fixed timeline. Category design engagements are typically multi-month, sometimes multi-quarter, depending on the complexity of the category being created and the readiness of the leadership team. There's no fixed start-to-finish duration like PitchKitchen's 90-day sprint.
Does Play Bigger do execution or just strategy?
Play Bigger focuses on category design strategy and Lightning Strike mobilization planning. Their core deliverable is the category strategy and the playbook for dominating it. They do not redesign your homepage, rebuild your sales deck, train your sales team on the new positioning, or set up AI tools. If you need any of that execution, you'll need to hire a separate execution partner. PitchKitchen, by contrast, includes all of that execution as part of its 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint.
What's the difference between Play Bigger and PitchKitchen?
Play Bigger and PitchKitchen solve different problems. Play Bigger is for companies designing and dominating an entirely NEW market category — invention work. PitchKitchen is for B2B founders who need sharper positioning inside an EXISTING market and full execution to ship that positioning into homepage, sales deck, AI Brand Twin, and sales training. Play Bigger is premium, selective, and strategy-focused (~$100K+). PitchKitchen is fixed-price ($17K–$75K), execution-included, and sprint-based.
Do I actually need category design?
Probably not. Category design is a real and powerful discipline, but it only works if you genuinely have a new category to create. Most B2B founders (even ambitious ones) are competing inside an existing category — their problem isn't that they need to invent a new market, it's that their positioning inside the existing market is unclear. If that's you, PitchKitchen is the better fit. If you're genuinely attempting to invent a new category and have the budget for premium consulting, Play Bigger is the right call.
Can PitchKitchen help with category design?
PitchKitchen's Magnetic Messaging Framework includes category positioning work — defining the unique category your company can credibly own — but it's distinct from the full Play Bigger 'invent a new market' methodology. We're better suited to founders who need sharper positioning and execution inside an existing or adjacent category, not full category creation from scratch. If your strategy genuinely requires inventing a new market, Play Bigger or Category Pirates is the right fit.
How much does PitchKitchen cost?
The 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint is $17K–$75K depending on scope (company size, number of stakeholders, and activation needs). That includes all deliverables across the three months: Magnetic Messaging Framework, 1-on-1 messaging therapy intakes, Story-Driven Homepage Wireframe, Discovery Prompter Sales Deck, AI Brand Twin (deployed as an OpenAI Custom GPT, Gemini Gem, and Claude Project), Lead Magnet, Email Outreach Sequences, AI Sales Training, and Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) strategy. You own everything at the end.
What is the 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint?
It's PitchKitchen's flagship engagement. Over 90 days, we excavate the truth about why your company matters (Month 1), build your AI Brand Twin and launch-ready toolkit (Month 2), and deploy the new story across sales, marketing, and AI (Month 3). The Sprint delivers a complete go-to-market system at a fixed price, with you owning everything when the engagement ends.
What is an AI Brand Twin?
Your AI Brand Twin is a custom large language model deployment trained on your Magnetic Messaging Framework. It lives as an OpenAI Custom GPT, a Gemini Gem, AND a Claude Project — same strategic brain, three surfaces. It writes 100% on-brand sales emails, proposals, follow-ups, LinkedIn posts, and content in seconds.
What if I already worked with Play Bigger?
Great — you have a category strategy. PitchKitchen can take that work and translate it into shipped execution: a rebuilt homepage that lands the new category, a sales deck that arms your team to sell it, an AI Brand Twin trained on the category narrative, and sales training so reps can actually deliver the new story in customer conversations. We don't compete with Play Bigger — we extend their strategic work into the execution layer.
How do I get started with PitchKitchen?
Book a free strategy call with Greg Rosner. He'll walk through your current story, where it's leaking, and whether the 90-Day Magnetic Messaging Sprint is the right fit for your stage and goals. There's no obligation and no sales pitch — just a real conversation about whether the work makes sense for your business right now.
